"best c++ preprocessor macro" question closure

by alan2here   Last Updated November 08, 2018 20:24 PM

I created a question on Stack Overflow about the best C++ pre-processor Macros to go with the other pre-existing question about the worst ones. I made the mistake of including some nifty examples in the question which--even if they weren't controversial--wasn't a good idea anyway. They should have been in an answer and probably a little time after the question was asked. The question was closed before anyone could give an answer. Most comments on the question were on the macro examples I had given but there were a few supportive ones of the idea of the thread (if not of the usefulness of my examples).

I can't find the thread anymore. Was it deleted? If so may I retry?



Answers 3


There's little point, it is very likely that it will just get closed again. This time probably with a flurry of downvotes from ticked-off users. Review the FAQ for the kind of questions you should not ask. Yours seems to match the first three bullets:

  • every answer is equally valid: “What’s your favorite ______?”
  • your answer is provided along with the question, and you expect more answers: “I use ______ for ______, what do you use?”
  • there is no actual problem to be solved: “I’m curious if other people feel like I do.”
Uphill Luge
Uphill Luge
March 16, 2011 15:58 PM

I don't know if it was deleted, since I'm not a 10k user, but I humbly submit that you may not retry. "List of X" questions like "what's the worst C++ preprocessor" were wildly popular when SO started. Then they landed in sort of a gray area during 2010 with half the community loving them and half hating them. Today the policy is pretty solidly "questions like this are off-topic, but we're not going to actively hunt down and delete old ones."

Pops
Pops
March 16, 2011 15:58 PM

enter image description here

The "pre-existing questions" exist for historical reasons; new subjective questions are no longer allowed.

Andreas Bonini
Andreas Bonini
March 16, 2011 15:58 PM

Related Questions



I want to understand why my question was closed

Updated July 27, 2018 03:24 AM

How to appeal a closed question?

Updated August 14, 2016 08:10 AM

What if the Closed Question decision is not fair?

Updated September 20, 2018 12:24 PM

Why was this closed as "not a real question"

Updated July 27, 2016 08:10 AM