Margarine in place of shortening

by Zmart   Last Updated September 11, 2019 22:17 PM

According to the Wikipedia article on shortening, it seems as though margarine is considered shortening.

Has anyone substituted margarine for shortening in any recipes, and can you report your results?

Answers 3

Margarine is essentially 80% hydrogenated vegetable oil, the rest being mostly water and a touch of coloring and flavoring.

Shortening is essentially 100% hydrogenated vegetable oil.

That means that to truly substitute shortening versus margarine, you would need 5 units of margarine, versus 4 units of shortening plus one unit of water.

However, in many, many applications substituting 1:1 is well within the tolerance of recipes. This applies to almost all savory cooking, and most baking including breads, quick breads, cookies, and cakes.

August 03, 2013 02:22 AM

I do not use margarine in any cookie recipes since the margarine is not what it used to be. The cookies that have margarine in them do not hold their shape and spread all over the cookie sheet. I use real butter.

Margaret Scott
Margaret Scott
December 22, 2013 21:39 PM

I always use butter when baking biscuits, cookies, cakes, pie crusts and brownie slices... Perfect results every time.

September 11, 2019 21:30 PM

Related Questions

Butter vs Margarine

Updated March 01, 2017 01:17 AM

Heating Margarine in Pan = loss of calories?

Updated August 12, 2019 04:17 AM

Bete Noir -- no dairy

Updated April 16, 2019 19:17 PM