Placement of a modal

by Nick Rucci   Last Updated July 09, 2018 17:16 PM

Currently, I am going into an application where there was a decision made to have modals slide into the screen from the right but stay snapped to that right window border.

modal right

From experience in other applications, I have seen modals always be dead center in the screen or centered horizontally.

enter image description here

I am unsure if this is something that should be continued with or if I should push more modals being in the center of the page.

Any help would be appreciated.



Answers 2


I think modals should always be in the top half of the screen otherwise it's just confusing for the user.

Dictatorboy
Dictatorboy
July 09, 2018 16:59 PM

It's not that crazy an idea. Sure, I always think of modals appearing in the middle of the screen, but Mac software (often) slides modals out from the window header.

MacOS Modal

You ought to mock up a right-edge modal and have some people try it out. (Don't warn them about the modal ahead of time.) See how they react to it when they see it for the first time. Me, I'd probably stop and wonder at it for a minute.

Ken Mohnkern
Ken Mohnkern
July 09, 2018 17:10 PM

Related Questions


Are modal dialogs WCAG compliant?

Updated September 28, 2016 09:06 AM

Display Modal over another Modal, it's really a sin?

Updated August 09, 2018 22:16 PM

Modal Window with Tab Menu font sizes (Prominence)

Updated September 20, 2017 18:16 PM